Usually whenever times are given, they are considering having a day of times you to do maybe not suits with that time as it inside real record. One example takes place in Harry Potter therefore the Prisoner out-of Azkaban when Sybill Trelawney means sixteen Oct while the Friday, even when 16 Oct 1993 are a monday.

You will be able, but not unrealistic, you to definitely Fudge is speaing frankly about a distant ancestor, given that Thatcher grabbed office before Fudge purportedly turned Minister to own Secret

There are also contradictions into the courses in this area. Such as for instance, in Harry Potter additionally the Goblet away from Flames, both 1 September and you will 2 Sep are provided as Mondays and, inside Harry Potter in addition to Prisoner out of Azkaban, Buckbeak’s trial is set into the 20 April, but careful parsing of one’s text message implies that this may keeps took place no after than just March.

And additionally, inside the Harry Potter while the Goblet out of Fire they say your Champions were selected to the Tuesday 30 Oct, however, 30 Oct try a monday when you look at the 1994. However, it had been later on reported that twenty two November is a monday, that it was in 1994.

For the chapter 7 regarding Quidditch From the Decades, they claim the first Quidditch Business Glass happened in the 1473. If for example the title was kept all few years, this issues to your declaration inside Goblet regarding Fire that the 1994 World Glass was the new 422nd. If the Quidditch From Many years is right, the 422nd Quidditch Globe Mug carry out indeed fall in the year 3161, however, if Cup out-of Flames excellent, the first Community Cup got held in the 306.

Historic dilemmas

Although the series, with regards to the timeline based on the fresh Chamber from Treasures source, is set throughout the nineties, the latest show tend to looks as though it is devote the brand new late 1990s in order to mid-2000s, more or less concurrent to the book of the instructions. During the Harry Potter and also the Half of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a male pronoun to mention into “predecessor” of your Perfect Minister of one’s British. According to more than schedule, this should take place in summer time from 1996, when the Prime Minister is actually John Big, whoever instantaneous predecessor is actually a female (is the reason very first ending up in Fudge, the book mentions this new election, however, Significant was not initially chose and only got more than immediately following Thatcher retired.

(Even if you can believe a situation in which Fudge is actually delegated of the Minister to own Wonders to satisfy towards Prime Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller sized place of work.) Concurrently, brand new personality and you may reputation of the top Minister depicted seems to way more closely match that of Tony Blair than simply out of John Biggest. A blog post regarding the Every day Post cards one to Rowling was romantic toward up coming-Chancellor of your own Exchequer Gordon Brownish (have a tendency to seen as a rival so you’re able to Blair’s leadership of your Labour Cluster, just who been successful him and you will became Perfect Minister), hence she has been trying to tell you Blair’s terrible datingmentor.org/escort/davenport front. If for example the guides was basically invest connect having publication day away from Philosopher’s Stone, upcoming it feel manage take place in 2002 (immediately after Blair became Primary Minister).

An equivalent disease comes to Nicolas Flamel, who was stated as being 665 at the time of new very first guide, but Nicolas Flamel was a real historic figure and you will would not have reached one to ages up until 1996, around the go out the original publication try typed. Brand new rebuttal for it is the fact that time this new “real” Nicolas Flamel was given birth to will not communicate with the new Nicolas Flamel from Harry Potter.

Various other problem is obtainable of Rubeus Hagrid’s period since the Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It is suggested regarding the series that Hagrid obtained one status in this many years of his expulsion away from college or university in the 1942. However in that scene from Harry Potter while the Cup out of Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces from the Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper frequently convergence with Molly’s many years in school, it seems unlikely you to definitely she remembers a previous gamekeeper. However, you’ll be able you to Hagrid didn’t feel an excellent gamekeeper immediately once getting expelled, but alternatively been since the Ogg’s assistant. This is certainly plausible once the whenever Harry believes that he often end up being expelled having traveling on the broomstick as opposed to consent in his first year, he miracle in the event that he would be allowed to stay on as Hagrid’s assistant.